top of page

GREENS POWDERS (NUTRITION)

Aug 2, 2024
5 min read

Updated: 58 minutes ago

Greens powders are an easy way to get extra nutrition and energy on the days it's hard to eat enough vegetables. A lot of people with Lyme and MCAS are sensitive to green powders, but many tolerate them well. I've tolerated them for most of the past 13 years, but there have been years when I had to be very careful because of oxalates or histamine issues. This post compares some of the top greens powders on Fullscript, grouped by what may suit sensitive people best.


Short on time or energy? A quick-view graphic with the key points is at the bottom of this post.


Sensitive to oxalates or histamine? Read these first:

OXALATES


HISTAMINE INTOLERANCE EDUCATION


Buy links are right under each product. Sign up here first for the Fullscript discount (25% off):


MY FAVORITE: GREENS FIRST

If you see any kind of natural doctor or chiropractor, you may have seen Greens First in their office over the years. I first learned about it from my Lyme-literate doctor, and it's the one I've used the most. It's a full-spectrum formula with greens, fruits, probiotics, enzymes and sunflower lecithin. It has a lot of ingredients, so it may not suit the most sensitive.


Our family's favorite flavors: I like the green and berry, and my kids like the chocolate. It was the only greens powder they would drink.


Greens First PRO Berry tub

Greens First PRO, Berry (my flavor)

(also comes in Mint, Chocolate, Peach Mango and capsules)


WHAT TO WATCH FOR IF YOU'RE SENSITIVE

- Histamine: in a 2021 review of 10 low-histamine diets, fermented foods were the one thing every diet left out. Spinach and tomato contain histamine, and citrus, pineapple, papaya, strawberry and chocolate are often avoided too.

- Oxalates: leafy greens like spinach, tea, chocolate and nuts are high in oxalates. Our bodies also turn some vitamin C into oxalate, so watch drinks with a lot of added vitamin C.

- Probiotics: some people with histamine issues find a greens powder without added probiotics easier to start with. My post on probiotics for histamine issues has more:

PROBIOTICS FOR HISTAMINE ISSUES

- Stevia: if stevia bothers you, Premier Greens, EssentiaGreens and Reds Unflavored, Green Vibrance, Garden of Life Perfect Food (original) and Easy Being Green don't use it.


SIMPLER FORMULAS (FEWER COMMON TRIGGERS)

These have short ingredient lists with no fermented ingredients, probiotics or adaptogens.


Premier Greens by Premier Research Labs

Seven greens with nothing added, not even flavor. A simple formula that leans more MCAS friendly (everyone is different). It has a small amount of spinach.


Premier Greens powder jar

Premier Greens powder (also comes in capsules)


Indigo Greens by Ortho Molecular

No fermented ingredients, probiotics, adaptogens or grasses. It's fruit-forward and has spinach, beet, orange and pineapple. The powder has stevia and the capsules don't.


Indigo Greens powder tub

Indigo Greens powder (also comes in capsules)


Additional options:

Tablets with grass juices, spirulina and dandelion. No spinach or beet.


Capsules with vegetables only. No algae, fruit or sweetener. It does have spinach.


FEWER HIGH-OXALATE INGREDIENTS

I didn't find any greens powder tested as low-oxalate. These are based on the labels, which don't list spinach, beet or chocolate.


EssentiaGreens and Reds Unflavored by Designs for Health

An option shared for those watching oxalates. No sweetener, probiotics or adaptogens. It has wheat grass and tomato.


Designs for Health EssentiaGreens and Reds Unflavored tub

EssentiaGreens and Reds Unflavored


Banyan Botanicals Everyday Greens (above) also fits here.


FULL-SPECTRUM GREENS

These have long ingredient lists, often with probiotics, enzymes or herbs. Great for many people, but harder to sort out if you react.


Greens First (my favorite, above)


Easy Being Green by Ora Organic

I've used this one. No stevia (it uses monk fruit), and the maker posts test results for each batch. It has ashwagandha and citrus.


Ora Organic Easy Being Green tub

Easy Being Green (the one I've used)


Additional options:

Every amount is on the label, with probiotics (25 billion when made) and no stevia. It has ginkgo and vitamin K.


Organic grass and vegetable juices with probiotics and no sweetener. It has spinach, beet, tomato and pineapple.


FERMENTED GREENS (BE CAREFUL IF HISTAMINE-SENSITIVE)

These are on Fullscript, but fermented ingredients are a common histamine trigger: Dr. Mercola Organic Fermented Greens, Premier Fermented Greens, New Chapter All Flora, Progressive Labs Alkalizing Greens and Ancient Nutrition Organic SuperGreens.


SINGLE-INGREDIENT GREENS

One ingredient makes it much easier to test one thing at a time.


Moringa


Spirulina

A 2023 review notes that spirulina can carry toxins, such as microcystins, so it's worth choosing a brand that tests for purity.


SPIRULINA



Chlorella

CHLORELLA


Broccoli sprout (sulforaphane)

SulforaXym by Tomorrow's Nutrition, a single-source base idea (broccoli sprout based).


SULFORAPHANE



AG1 AND IM8

These two are very popular, and both are on Fullscript. Here's what I found when I compared them with greens powders.

- They're all-in-one drinks: greens plus a multivitamin, probiotics, herbs and more. AG1 Pro has over 80 ingredients and IM8 has about 90.

- Part of each formula is a blend that doesn't show how much of each ingredient you're getting.

- They cost about 2 to 3 times more per serving than most greens powders.

- With so many ingredients, it's harder to figure out what you're reacting to.

- AG1 Pro has 5 grams of creatine and stevia.

- IM8 has berberine and 900 mg of vitamin C, and the original version has ginkgo.

- Both are NSF Certified for Sport (for IM8, the Pro version).



BEFORE YOU START

- Start with a small amount, and add only one new thing at a time.

- If you take a blood thinner like warfarin, ask your doctor first. Greens have vitamin K, and people on warfarin need to keep their vitamin K steady. Some formulas also have ginkgo.

- If you've had kidney stones, ask your doctor about oxalates and high-dose vitamin C.

- Some of these contain potassium (IM8 470 mg, AG1 Pro 250 mg, Green Vibrance 221 mg and Perfect Food 220 mg per serving). ALWAYS ask your doctor before adding potassium.

- Always ask your doctor before adding anything new.


MY EXPERIENCE

- I use greens to boost my nutrition and as an overall "feel better drink."

- My Lyme-literate doctor suggested Greens First for me.

- I've tolerated greens powders for most of the past 13 years. During the years I had to be very careful with oxalates or histamine, I used simpler options and eventually went back to Greens First.

- I've used practically all of these greens powders at one time or another. I like to rotate because I get bored, or based on my sensitivity at the time.


RELATED POSTS

NUTRITION IDEAS


NUTRITIONAL DEFICIENCIES AND LYME


FOOD AND DIET RELATED - POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS

SOURCES

Karr et al., Dietary Oxalates and Kidney Inflammation review, Integrative Medicine, 2024

Gogna et al., Spirulina benefits and safety review, J Am Nutr Assoc, 2023

Sanchez-Perez et al., Low-histamine diets review, Nutrients, 2021 (older source, still worth reading)

Bargagli et al., Dietary Oxalate and Kidney Outcomes, Nutrients, 2020 (older source, still worth reading)

NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, Vitamin K Fact Sheet


Disclaimer: Rise Above Lyme makes no claims about any possible benefit of using any product mentioned within this site. Always consult with your doctor before adding anything. The information shared is based on personal experience, years of accumulated researched resources from Lyme Literate doctors and polls conducted within Lyme groups from actual patient experience using these solution ideas.

Comments


bottom of page