SUGAR SUBSTITUTES AND LYME DISEASE: SAFER SWEETENERS
Updated: 27 minutes ago
I personally love using a combo of monk fruit, pure maple syrup and coconut sugar in baked goods. In my coffee, I use liquid monk fruit. I don't really care for stevia, but I do use it once in a while. What's your favorite?
Short on time or energy? A quick-view graphic with the key points is at the bottom of this post.
Most of the Lyme-literate doctors I trust ask their patients to cut out sugar. Here's why, and what I use instead. For the full way of eating, see my Lyme diet post:
THE LYME DISEASE DIET: AN ANTI-INFLAMMATORY WAY TO EAT
Buy links are right under each product. Sign up here first for the Fullscript discount:
WHY SUGAR MATTERS WITH LYME
- Dr. Daniel Cameron, a past ILADS president, explains that the immune system already seems overactive with Lyme, and sugar and alcohol can push it over the top. People may flare, sleep poorly and crave even more sugar.
- Dr. Richard Horowitz advises his patients to eat very low-carb in general, since at least half of them have blood sugar swings, and simple carbs can feed Candida.
- The hopeful part: Dr. Horowitz says that once you eat fewer sweets, your sweet cravings really do fade.
SWEETENERS TO AVOID
Dr. Horowitz cautions against these artificial sweeteners:
- Aspartame
- Sucralose
- Saccharin
- Acesulfame potassium (Ace-K)
- Erythritol
Research also raises questions about some sweeteners:
- In a 2022 trial of 120 healthy adults, all four sweeteners tested for two weeks (saccharin, sucralose, aspartame and stevia) changed the gut bacteria, but only saccharin and sucralose made the body's blood sugar response worse. The effects were different for each person.
- In 2023 lab tests, an impurity found in sucralose (and possibly formed in the gut) damaged DNA, and both it and sucralose weakened lab-grown gut lining tissue.
- In studies of thousands of people having heart checkups, higher blood levels of erythritol (2023) and xylitol (2024) were tied to more heart attacks, strokes and deaths over 3 years. In lab tests, both also made blood platelets clot more easily. In a small test of 8 healthy people, blood levels stayed high for more than 2 days after one erythritol drink.
- In a 2026 Tulane study of adults with overweight or obesity, when people's erythritol levels dropped during a weight-loss diet program, it was linked to better heart risk scores.
It's so frustrating to me how many products add erythritol. I wish companies would stop choosing it. Be sure to check sugar-free chocolate chips, because so many brands use it.
XYLITOL AND DOGS
Xylitol is very dangerous for dogs. It can cause dangerously low blood sugar and liver failure. It shows up in gum, mints, some foods and candies, toothpaste and sugar-free chewable vitamins, so keep these away from pets.
BETTER CHOICES
MONK FRUIT
Dr. Horowitz feels monk fruit may be safer, though it still needs more study. A 2025 review of 5 trials found monk fruit lowered blood sugar after a meal by 10 to 18%, with no serious side effects. Many monk fruit products are blended with other sweeteners like erythritol, even some called "pure monk fruit," so always read the ingredient list. For baking, I usually can't find monk fruit without erythritol in stores, so I buy it online.
Organic Liquid Monk Fruit by NOW Foods (the one I use in my coffee)
HONEY, MAPLE SYRUP AND FRUIT
For everyday sweetening, Dr. Horowitz lists small amounts of honey, maple syrup or fruit as better options. Honey and maple syrup are still sugar, so limit or skip them (along with sweet and dried fruits) on a low-mold diet. If you use maple syrup, make sure it's pure maple. I find Costco has the best price on it.
COCONUT SUGAR
Dr. Horowitz also lists coconut sugar as an option in small amounts. It's still a form of sugar, so limit it on a low-mold diet too.
Organic Coconut Sugar by Foods Alive
STEVIA
Stevia is a sweetener made from the stevia plant. I feel stevia ruins baked goods, so I only use it in other things. A 2024 review of 26 studies with 1,439 people found stevia was linked to slightly lower blood sugar, though the evidence is still limited and more trials are needed.
Stevia extract is sometimes used to help break down biofilm in Lyme. On a 2025 LymeDisease.org podcast, naturopathic physician Dr. Jaquel Patterson named it as one option, and Dr. Horowitz has said, "No one is claiming stevia is a cure for Lyme disease." In our groups, it isn't as popular as other biofilm options, and it's often debated: some people believe it works, while others laugh at the idea. It was never part of my own treatment.
BIOFILMS - POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS
Stevia by NutraMedix (a liquid stevia leaf extract)
GLUTEN-FREE BAKING TIP
If you bake gluten-free cookies, let the dough rest in the fridge before baking. Even a few hours can make a difference: the flour soaks up moisture, so the cookies don't spread as much. I prefer 24 hours for the best texture and taste.
BEFORE YOU START
- Always ask your doctor before adding anything new.
For more food ideas and recipes, join my Rise Above Lyme * All About Food group on Facebook:
RELATED POSTS
HYPOGLYCEMIA (LOW BLOOD SUGAR) AND LYME DISEASE
CANDIDA EDUCATION
FOOD AND DIET RELATED - POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS

SOURCES
Global Lyme Alliance, Lyme Disease and Alcohol, with Dr. Daniel Cameron (2023)
ILADS, Past Presidents (no date shown)
Dr. Richard Horowitz, What Are Food Additives, Dyes, and Artificial Sweeteners Doing to Your Health? (2025)
Dr. Richard Horowitz, Mold Is Everywhere and It Can Make You Sick: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Mycotoxicosis (2025)
Suez and others, Personalized microbiome-driven effects of non-nutritive sweeteners on human glucose tolerance, Cell (2022)
Schiffman and others, Toxicological and pharmacokinetic properties of sucralose-6-acetate and its parent sucralose: in vitro screening assays, Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health Part B (2023)
Witkowski and others, The artificial sweetener erythritol and cardiovascular event risk, Nature Medicine (2023)
Witkowski and others, Xylitol is prothrombotic and associated with cardiovascular risk, European Heart Journal (2024)
Heianza and others (Tulane University), Declines in plasma erythritol and improvements in cardiovascular disease risk (title shortened), American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2026)
Zare and others, Effect of stevia on blood glucose and HbA1C: A meta-analysis, Diabetes and Metabolic Syndrome (2024)
Pet Poison Helpline, Xylitol Is Toxic To Dogs (no date shown)
Cleveland Clinic, Is Monk Fruit a Healthy Sweetener? (2021, older source, still worth reading)
Kaim and Labus, Monk Fruit Extract and Sustainable Health: A PRISMA-Guided Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials, Nutrients (2025)
LymeDisease.org, PODCAST: Understanding the unique burdens of Lyme on women, with Dr. Jaquel Patterson (2025)
LymeDisease.org, LYME SCI: What's the story about stevia? (2017, older source, still worth reading)
Disclaimer: Rise Above Lyme makes no claims about any possible benefit of using any product mentioned within this site. Always consult with your doctor before adding anything. The information shared is based on personal experience, years of accumulated researched resources from Lyme Literate doctors and polls conducted within Lyme groups from actual patient experience using these solution ideas.







Comments