top of page

CAN YOU GET LYME DISEASE MORE THAN ONCE? (REINFECTION)

Jul 26, 2024
8 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

Many people ask if you can get Lyme twice, hoping that having it once means they can't get it again. Sadly, that isn't how Lyme works. Catching it again from a new tick bite is called reinfection. I see this come up in our groups almost every week. Ticks can carry different germs and different strains, so a new bite can bring a brand new infection, even after treatment and even years later. I wanted to understand why, so I dug into what my most trusted sources and the newest research say. Knowing this can help you protect yourself and act fast if it happens.


Short on time or energy? A quick-view graphic with the key points is at the bottom of this post.


Everything about tick bites, all in one place:

TICK BITE EDUCATION


WHAT ILADS SAYS

- You can be infected with Lyme more than once. When symptoms return after treatment, ILADS says doctors must consider both the old infection relapsing and a brand new infection.

- After a known black-legged (deer) tick bite, ILADS says 20 days of doxycycline started promptly may prevent Lyme. Mouse studies show this works far less well when it is started more than 48 hours after the tick is removed.

- Anyone who has been bitten should know what symptoms to watch for and how to prevent the next bite.


WHY HAVING LYME ONCE DOESN'T PROTECT YOU

- The Lyme bacteria come in many strains. In 2019, IGeneX noted there are at least 18 known strains, so a new bite can bring the same strain that infected you before or a different one.

- One tick can carry several strains at once. In a 2016 Yale-led study of 98 infected deer ticks from the US and southern Canada, about 7 in 10 held a mix of Lyme strains, so a single bite may pass on more than one.

- One tick can also carry more than one germ. A 2026 study of testing data from 13,437 deer tick nymphs from the eastern US (sent in from 2013 to 2024) found that, of the 4 germs tested, Lyme plus Babesia was the most common pairing where they overlapped, and 3 of the 4 pairings the researchers studied showed up more often than chance alone would explain.

- Any protection you build may be narrow. Dr. Daniel Cameron, a past president of ILADS, explains that modeling studies suggest protection may cover only the one strain that infected you, perhaps for six to nine years, while the next tick may carry a different strain.

- Even that protection may be weak. In a 2015 study in mice, Lyme infection kept the body from building long-lasting antibody memory for months, which left the mice open to reinfection, even with the same strain. This was in mice, not people.

- Another bite can also bring germs other than Lyme, such as Babesia or Anaplasma, as Dr. Cameron points out.

EHRLICHIA AND ANAPLASMA

- Babesia may also be caught again from a new bite. A 2021 Yale case report described a healthy 62-year-old doctor in New York who had Babesia twice, 3 years apart, and the authors believe the second illness was most likely a new infection.

BABESIA DIRECTORY


HOW OFTEN IT HAPPENS

- One of the largest looks at this comes from a Lyme clinic in Slovenia, published in 2025. Of 12,384 Lyme rash cases seen there from 1990 to 2014, 1,962 (15.8%) were in people who had been treated for Lyme before. Some people got Lyme again two, three or more times, and one person had a new Lyme rash 7 more times after the first.

- The typical time between the first infection and the new one was about 6 years, ranging from 3 months to 23 years. New infections happened after every earlier form of Lyme the study looked at, including Lyme that had reached the nerves or joints, so no earlier form of Lyme gave full protection against a new infection. This was in Europe, where the Lyme bacteria species differ from those in the US.

- A weakened immune system is linked to a higher risk. A 2026 study from the same clinic found that people with a moderately or severely weakened immune system (such as after an organ transplant, with blood cancers, within a year of chemotherapy, or on medicines that calm the immune system) had about 3 times higher odds of getting Lyme again.

IMMUNE SYSTEM EDUCATION


A NEW INFECTION CAN LOOK DIFFERENT

- In the 2026 Slovenian (European) study, rashes from a new infection less often caused symptoms where the rash was (42.5% vs. 53.6%), less often showed up as several rashes at once (4.4% vs. 7.3%) and grew faster than first-time rashes.

- The 2025 Slovenian study saw the same pattern (5.5% vs. 7.4% with several rashes). Dr. Daniel Cameron, a past president of ILADS, points out that this doesn't mean a new infection will be milder. In his view, new symptoms after a tick exposure shouldn't automatically be blamed on the old illness and should be checked on their own.

- One patient story shared by Bay Area Lyme Foundation in 2019 shows how a possible new infection can look nothing like the first. She was treated after a bullseye rash in 2007, then more than 10 years later developed a heart rhythm problem and new joint and muscle pain. She never saw a tick or a rash, and testing showed Lyme, Babesia and Mycoplasma.

- A new infection isn't always just a rash. Doctors have reported reinfections that affected the heart, including complete heart block in a 6-year-old boy (a 2010 case report) and in a 38-year-old farmer (a 2009 case report). The farmer's IgM Lyme test was negative, and his heart block went away with antibiotics.

CARDIOLOGY (LYME CARDITIS AND POTS)

- Many people never get a rash or never notice one. See what Lyme and co-infection rashes can look like:

BULLSEYE AND OTHER RASHES IN LYME AND CO-INFECTIONS


WHY TESTING GETS TRICKY THE SECOND TIME

- Standard Lyme tests look for antibodies, which can take weeks to build up, so an early negative test doesn't rule out a new infection. Antibodies can also stay in your blood for years after treatment, so a positive antibody test alone doesn't show a new infection.

- In the 2026 Slovenian (European) study, people with a new infection were more likely to already test IgG positive (63% vs. 52.8%) and less likely to test IgM positive (35% vs. 43.6%) than people infected for the first time.

IGG VS. IGM ANTIBODIES IN LYME DISEASE: WHAT YOUR TEST RESULTS MEAN

- Standard tests miss many early cases anyway. A 2026 Bay Area Lyme Foundation study found that common FDA-cleared Lyme tests missed 64% to 78% of early Lyme cases, including people with the Lyme rash.

- One clue doctors can use: Columbia's Lyme center explained in 2018 that a big jump in Lyme antibody levels, compared with a test taken after your last treatment, may point to a new infection (they gave the C6 test as an example). Your doctor can help sort out whether it is a new infection or the old one coming back.

- Hope on the way: Tufts researchers found a new kind of antibody (anti-lipid antibodies) that shows up early and drops after treatment. A short-term rise may one day help show a new, active infection. This is not a test you can order yet, and larger studies are needed.


LYME DISEASE AND CO-INFECTION TESTING


NEW INFECTION OR RELAPSE?

- Symptoms coming back can also mean a relapse of the old infection, active co-infections, an ongoing immune or inflammatory reaction, or another illness.

- Not every returning rash means a new bite. In a 2023 Bay Area Lyme Foundation interview, Lyme-literate Dr. Kenneth Liegner described a patient whose rash cleared with antibiotics given for a suspected skin infection, came back a couple of weeks later, then cleared and came back again after a second round. Only then was Lyme found. Dr. Liegner thinks he then gave the man IV ceftriaxone, and to his knowledge the man fully recovered. Dr. Liegner also says many studies show the Lyme infection can live through antibiotic treatment.

- In a 2023 Tulane mouse study from Monica Embers's team, none of the single antibiotics tested cleared the persistent Lyme bacteria, while some combinations did. This was in mice, not people, but it is one reason some researchers believe Lyme can survive treatment.


CHRONIC LYME


MAINTAIN REMISSION / PREVENT RELAPSE EDUCATION


WHAT YOU CAN DO

- Prevent bites: repellent, treated clothing and daily tick checks, even if you've had Lyme before.

TICK REPELLENT (FOR BODY AND YARD)

- Save any tick that bites you and get it tested:

TICK TESTING: FIND OUT WHAT IT CARRIED

- Call your Lyme-literate doctor right away after any new bite, even a tiny one. Don't wait for symptoms.

- Keep a simple symptom log, so you and your doctor can spot a new pattern early.


MY EXPERIENCE

As far as I know, I've never had a new tick bite since my infection, but I know how fast one bite can change everything. One tiny nymph bite, and I had extreme symptoms in under 2 hours. My blood tests later showed Rocky Mountain spotted fever, 2 strains of Babesia, Lyme and Bartonella.

I had a perfect bullseye rash right where I was bitten, though back then I had never heard of a bullseye rash or what it meant. It faded away, and two years later it reappeared in the exact same spot. I hadn't had any antibiotics yet. I was still bouncing from doctor to doctor, showing them the rash whenever it was visible. My doctor called it an "odd" rash, said it wasn't ringworm, and suggested a cream. I don't hear about a rash coming back like this very often, which is why I'm sharing it here.

My personal opinion: even if I had no symptoms and no bullseye rash, I would still want 6 to 8 weeks of antibiotics after a new bite. I'll admit I'm a little paranoid, but that comes from what Lyme did to my life and from watching people I love go through it too. Please talk with your doctor about what is right for you.


RELATED POSTS


NEW TICK BITE? WHAT TO ASK YOUR DOCTOR.


ANTIBIOTICS - WHY USING ONLY ONE IS NOT RECOMMENDED IN CHRONIC LYME


Can you get Lyme disease more than once (reinfection) quick-view graphic

SOURCES

Dr. Daniel Cameron, "Can You Get Lyme Disease More Than Once?" (updated November 2026)

ILADS, "Lyme Disease Basics for Providers" (page updated October 2026)

Tufts University School of Medicine, "Moving Toward Better Tests and Treatments for Lyme Disease" (June 30, 2026)

Bay Area Lyme Foundation, "New Bay Area Lyme Foundation Study Shows Common FDA-Cleared Lyme Tests Miss 64-78% of Early Cases, Underscores Urgent Need for Improved Diagnostics" (April 21, 2026)

Strle and others, "Clinical data on symptomatic cutaneous reinfections due to Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato in Slovenia," Infection (February 17, 2026)

Grimaudo and others, "Geographic variation in risk of blacklegged tick-borne coinfections in the eastern United States," Ticks and Tick-borne Diseases (February 3, 2026)

Strle and others, "Lower Frequency of Multiple Erythema Migrans Skin Lesions in Lyme Reinfections, Europe," Emerging Infectious Diseases (April 2025)

Alruwaili and others, "Superior efficacy of combination antibiotic therapy versus monotherapy in a mouse model of Lyme disease," Frontiers in Microbiology (November 21, 2023)

Bay Area Lyme Foundation, "On the Front Lines of Lyme Treatment: A Conversation with Pioneer Kenneth Liegner, MD" (April 23, 2023)

Ho and others, "Recurrence of Human Babesiosis Caused by Reinfection," Emerging Infectious Diseases (October 2021, older source, still worth reading)

Bay Area Lyme Foundation, patient story "Susie M." (2019, older source, still worth reading)

IGeneX, "Can You Get Lyme Disease Twice?" (2019, older source, still worth reading)

Columbia University Lyme and Tick-Borne Diseases Research Center, FAQ (2018, older source, still worth reading)

Walter and others, "Vectors as Epidemiological Sentinels: Patterns of Within-Tick Borrelia burgdorferi Diversity," PLoS Pathogens (July 14, 2016, older source, still worth reading)

Elsner and others, "Suppression of Long-Lived Humoral Immunity Following Borrelia burgdorferi Infection," PLoS Pathogens (July 2, 2015, older source, still worth reading)

Goldberg and Rotondo, "Complete atrioventricular block due to Lyme reinfection in a six year-old boy," Medicine and Health Rhode Island (2010, older source, still worth reading)

Guenther and others, "Reversible complete heart block by re-infection with Borrelia burgdorferi with negative IgM-antibodies," Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift, article in German (2009, older source, still worth reading)


Disclaimer: Rise Above Lyme makes no claims about any possible benefit of using any product mentioned within this site. Always consult with your doctor before adding anything. The information shared is based on personal experience, years of accumulated researched resources from Lyme Literate doctors and polls conducted within Lyme groups from actual patient experience using these solution ideas.

Comments


bottom of page